“Investigation of the 1964 Murders of Michael Schwerner, James Chaney, and Andrew Goodman: Case Closed.”
So stated federal and Mississippi state officials this past week in declaring at an end their long attempt to bring to justice all the men who had committed one of the most notorious crimes in modern American history – the murder of three civil rights workers near Philadelphia, Miss. in June 1964.
Although seven men involved in the murder were convicted in 1967 of federal conspiracy charges, most of the mob of at least 19 escaped justice. Four decades later, however, the Mississippi attorney general’s office revived the investigation and, based on new evidence, arrested Edgar Ray Killen, the ringleader of the death squad, and charged him with three counts of manslaughter.
Old, locked up
In 2005, a Mississippi jury found him guilty, and he was sentenced to serve 60 years in the Mississippi state prison. He is, at 91, still alive.
The Justice Department decision is only the latest in its long investigation of more than 100 suspected racist murders in the South in the postwar decades to encounter witnesses holding to past lies or refusals to cooperate, and the time-driven obstacles of witnesses having died or no longer able to reliably remember, and of pieces of physical evidence having vanished.
(Independent scholars said they’ve identified hundreds more cases that also deserve federal investigation.)
I suggest we adopt another perspective. We should make a parallel declaration to that of federal and state officials about the murder of the three civil rights workers: “Investigation of the 1964 Murders of Michael Schwerner, James Chaney, and Andrew Goodman: Case Never Closed – The Judgment of History.”
What I remember most about the night of June 21, 1964 – when my brother and I heard that three civil rights workers in Mississippi were missing – is the feeling of dread and certainty.
They’re dead, of course. They’ve been murdered for sure. Their bodies would not be found for 44 days, buried 15 feet beneath an earthen dam near Philadelphia, Miss.
The dread and the certainty that racial violence, especially in the South, could and would strike at any moment – were part of being a Black American in those years as they had always been.
That was the barbarism Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. referred to in his “Dream” speech at the Lincoln Memorial when he said, “I am not unmindful that some of you have come here out of great trials and tribulations. … from areas where your quest for freedom has left you battered by the storms of persecution and staggered by the winds of police brutality.”
Last week’s development underscores the extraordinary and damning fact of America’s history that its White majority for so long tolerated a substantial chain of crimes against Black Americans that will never be redeemed by the legal system. But something else can be done to redeem the tragedy of the three civil rights workers, and others who perished.
Scholars and other writers can continue to build on such works Taylor Branch’s magnificent trilogy of King and the civil rights movement that does describe what happened the night the men were murdered to add new details, and expand the responsibility for these crimes against humanity in the ‘court’ of history.
Further, federal and state officials’ decision should remind us of several other things that occurred after the murder of James Chaney, Andrew Goodman and Michael Schwerner.
For one thing, a week after they disappeared, 300 more volunteers from across the country arrived in Mississippi to reinforce the civil rights groups’ “Freedom Summer” project, and 400 more came within a month. For another, within two weeks, President Johnson signed the landmark Civil Rights Act of 1964.
Finally, throughout the South, civil rights activism continued, leading the next year to the landmark Voting Rights Act of 1965. Ensuring that Black Mississippians would have the unfettered right to vote was the primary focus of the 1964 Freedom Summer project there.
In other words, the civil rights forces’ work to make America a democracy went on. It went on because its activists took to heart the words of one of the movement’s most powerful anthems: “Keep your eyes on the prize, fight on.”
Lee A. Daniels is a former reporter for The Washington Post and the New York Times. He is writing a book on the Obama years and the 2016 election. Contact him at firstname.lastname@example.org.